I just found out that Magical-Menagerie is number 8 on the The 50 Greatest Harry Potter Fansites list that RAHP Online made. They had their viewers say their favorite sites and the top 50 were put into a video that you can see HERE. Coming in ahead of MM were:

10 – Daniel Radcliffe.com
9 – Harry Potter in Action
8 – Magical Menagerie
7 – Potter Puppet Pals
6 – Fans of Fantasy
5 – HPANA
4 – Evanna Lynch Fans
3 – The Leaky Cauldron
2 – Veritaserum
1 – Mugglenet

Congrats Everyone!